This winter compared to last...and will we see a normal recovery?

A couple weeks ago we posted a story on our Facebook page that said, climatologically speaking the harshest part of winter is now in our rear view mirror. Here's was the post.

We stated that since the days are getting longer, sunnier (very slowly) and temperatures are on the rise that in fact, climatologically speaking the worst is over with. However, we did put a caveat in the story which said we can still get some very good winter storms during the remainder of January into February. One astute reader mentioned that we stated something similar last year in a blog entry. Last winter we had a very dry and relatively snowless beginning to the winter and wondered what the chances were of it continuing. Needless to say we recovered quite nicely in the second half of winter. This winter, things might be just a bit tougher. Just for comparison sake, here was the mountain snowpack last year on this date.

And here's how it looked this year

Not a lot of differences. All locations were seeing below normal snow water equivalent values for both years. The Okanogan Highlands and the northern Cascades are doing a little better this year, and things are a little worse elsewhere.  Also, notice how poor the snow water numbers are for the southern Washington Cascades and the Oregon Cascades.  However, these maps aren't really telling the entire story. Why is that? If we choose to just look at the amount of precipitation which has fallen since October 1st (beginning of the water year) rather than the amount of water in the snowpack the winters are completely different. Here was 2014 through January 19th. Just like the drier than normal snowpack, the precipitation was similarly dry.

Oct 1 2013-Jan 13 2014 percent of normal precipitation

Now look at the data for this water year. What a difference a year makes! All basins are seeing normal to slightly wetter than normal conditions.

So what gives, why the big difference? In one-word temperatures. Temperatures this winter and late fall have been significantly warmer temperatures than what we saw last year. Much of what's been falling has been dropping as rain as opposed to snow. Take a look at the temperature departures from normal below. They exhibit a huge difference. In the first half of winter 2013-14 temperatures were well below normal.

Oct 1-December 2013 temperature departures. Note widespread below normal temperatures

 While this year...they have been generally well above normal. The swing from last winter to this winter is around 3-6°F warmer. That may not seem like a lot, but in terms of snow it makes a big difference.

Oct 1-Jan 18 temperature departures. Note widespread warmer than normal temperatures. 

Anyway we digress. We simply wanted to demonstrate that although we have seen similar snow totals to last winter in the mountains, how we got to those totals is completely different. Last year was an ENSO neutral year which often does not foretell what sort of winter to expect. This year is an El Nino winter (albeit a weak one). Typical El Nino winters deliver warmer than normal conditions (sure enough it has been warmer), and a variable precipitation signature. So let's examine some snowfall numbers across a few valley locations including Spokane, Wenatchee and the always snowy Holden Village (on Lake Chelan). Just like the mountains, most valley locations are seeing sharp snow deficits. In fact, most locations are seeing a top-10 least snow winter since 1949. We are utilizing 1949 since that year is when the NWS began keeping track of  El Nino/La Nina data.

Least 10 snowy Spokane winters through 1/19 since 1949

Least 10 snowy Wenatchee winters through 1/19 since 1949

Least 10 snowy Holden Village winters through 1/19 since 1949

So of those three sites, this year ranks as either the 5th or 6th least snowy winter through 1/19. But more importantly how did the rest of the winter fare and could the snowfall deficit be made up. The answer is an overwhelming no. In Spokane, none of the 10 least snowy years through 1/19 was able to recover to normal. The winter of 1989-90 was close. Last year was also somewhat close as much of the region saw a record or near record snows in February. However, those were not El Nino years. Of the El Nino years, three of them, the remainder of the winter failed to deliver more than 6 inches of snow.

For Wenatchee, two of the winters were able to recover to above normal levels after such a slow start to the snow season.  Both of those years were ENSO neutral years. During the El Nino years, the numbers were quite meager. The two El Nino winters on the list experienced snowfall of less than an inch through the remainder of the season. On average, less than 5" of snow typically falls during the remainder of the season. 

Now onto the ever snowy Holden Village area. The numbers for here spell bad news for heavy snow lovers. Of the 10 least snowy winters through 1/19, none were able to get back to normal. Last year was close (after an astounding and record breaking 142" of snow in February) as was 1989-90. Both of those years were ENSO neutral ones. The trends during an El Nino year are much less promising. Of the 4 El Nino years on the list, none were able to recover to normal levels. Additionally, 3 of the 4 El Nino years saw significantly less snow than normal through the remainder of the winter.

So climotology tells us the odds of recovering from such a slow start to the winter are slim and given our weak El Nino conditions the chances are even slimmer. However, keep in mind that long-term weather forecasting can prove a futile endeavor and ultimately anything can happen. 

Through the remainder of the month the weather pattern will not be conducive to adding significant amounts to our  snow totals. Although wet weather will likely return by the end of the week, this moisture will be accompanied by unusually warm temperatures at least over the mountains. The 6-10 and 8-14 day outlooks are calling for a good chance of warmer than normal temperatures and average or slightly wetter than normal conditions. 

8-14 day precipitation outlook

8-14 day temperature outlook